Talent selection and development in academy soccer is highly dependent on coach intuition. Given such reliance upon subjective inputs, a greater understanding towards the utility of coach intuition may prove invaluable. The present study investigated coach agreement, the associations between subjective and objective outcomes and prominent traits highlighted within player (de)selection. Academy players (n = 45, age = 14 ± 2yrs) and coaches (n = 10, age = 31 ± 5yrs) were recruited from a professional soccer academy. Objective assessments included tactical and psychological surveys, physical assessments (linear sprints, change of direction and jumping tasks) and performance analysis (performance assessment for team sports). Coach subjective player gradings were collected using a visual analogue scale aligned to the objective assessments. Lead and assistant coaches demonstrated poor-to-moderate agreements in perceived player skills (ICC = 0.48 to 0.76) and fair to almost perfect agreement in player (de)selection (ICC= 0.23-1.00, P <.001 to .26). However, coach agreement reduced as players aged. Likewise, a maturation related bias was present whereby biologically older players were selected over their lesser mature players. Moreover, coach intuition demonstrated a strong predictive capability to select players, whilst the study was incapable of distinguishing exclusive traits related to selection outcome.


Physiology, Youth, Psychology, Technical/Tactical, Maturation, Talent Identification,


  1. Bergkamp, T. L. G., Frencken, W. G. P., Niessen, A. S. M., Meijer, R. R., & den Hartigh, R. J. R. (2022). How soccer scouts identify talented players. European Journal of Sport Science, 22(7), 994–1004.
  2. Bidaurrazaga-Letona, I., Lekue, J. A., Amado, M., & Gil, S. M. (2019). Progression in Youth Soccer: Selection and Identification in Youth Soccer Players Aged 13–15 Years. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 33(9), 2548–2558.
  3. Collins, D., MacNamara, Á., & McCarthy, N. (2016). Super champions, champions, and almosts: Important differences and commonalities on the rocky road. Frontiers in Psychology, 6(JAN), 1–11.
  4. Cormack, S. J., Newton, R. U., McGulgan, M. R., & Doyle, T. L. A. (2008). Reliability of measures obtained during single and repeated countermovement jumps. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 3(2), 131–144.
  5. Cronin, J. B., Green, J. P., Levin, G. T., Brughelli, M. E., & Frost, D. M. (2007). EFFECT OF STARTING STANCE ON INITIAL SPRINT PERFORMANCE. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 21(3), 990–992.
  6. Deprez, D. N., Fransen, J., Lenoir, M., Philippaerts, R. M., & Vaeyens, R. (2015). A retrospective study on anthropometrical, physical fitness, and motor coordination characteristics that influence dropout, contract status, and first-team playing time in high-level soccer players aged eight to eighteen years. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 29(6), 1692–1704.
  7. Dugdale, J. H., McRobert, A. P., & Unnithan, V. B. (2021). Selected, Deselected, and Reselected: A Case Study Analysis of Attributes Associated With Player Reselection Following Closure of a Youth Soccer Academy. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 3, 633124.
  8. Dugdale, J. H., Sanders, D., Myers, T., Williams, A. M., & Hunter, A. M. (2020). A case study comparison of objective and subjective evaluation methods of physical qualities in youth soccer players. Journal of Sports Sciences, 38(11–12), 1304–1312.
  9. Elferink-gemser, M. T., Visscher, C., Richart, H., & Lemmink, K. A. P. M. (2004). Development of the tactical skills inventory for sports. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 99(3 I), 883–895.
  10. Emmonds, S., Till, K., Jones, B., Mellis, M., & Pears, M. (2016). Anthropometric, speed and endurance characteristics of English academy soccer players: Do they influence obtaining a professional contract at 18 years of age? International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching, 11(2), 212–218.
  11. Epstein, L. H., Valoski, A. M., Kalarchian, M. A., & McCurley, J. (1995). Do Children Lose and Maintain Weight Easier Than Adults: A Comparison of Child and Parent Weight Changes From Six Months to Ten Years. Obesity Research, 3(5), 411–417.
  12. Fanchini, M., Coutts, A. J., & Schena, F. (2014). Effect of Training Session Intensity Distribution on Session-RPE in Soccer Players. Effectiveness of Passive Mobilization on Vascular Function of Bedridden Oldest Old View project fatigue and biomechanics View project. Article in International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance.
  13. Fritz, C. O., Morris, P. E., & Richler, J. J. (2012). Effect size estimates: Current use, calculations, and interpretation. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 141(1), 2–18.
  14. Grant, S., Aitchison, T., Henderson, E., Christie, J., Zare, S., Mcmurray, J., & Dargie, H. (1997). A Comparison of the Reproducibility and the Sensitivity to Change of Visual Analogue Scales, Borg Scales, and Likert Scales in Normal Subjects During Submaximal Exercise, Chest, 116(5) (1999) 1208-17.
  15. Gréhaigne, J. F., Godbout, P., & Bouthier, D. (1997). Performance assessment in team sports. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 16(4), 500–516.
  16. Hendry, D. T., Williams, A. M., & Hodges, N. J. (2018). Coach ratings of skills and their relations to practice, play and successful transitions from youth-elite to adult-professional status in soccer. Journal of Sports Sciences, 36(17), 2009–2017.
  17. Hopkins, W. G. (2002). A scale of magnitudes for effect statistics. Sportscience, 5, 1–7.
  18. Jennings, D., Cormack, S., Coutts, A. J., Boyd, L., & Aughey, R. J. (2010). The Validity and Reliability of GPS Units for Measuring Distance in Team Sport Specific Running Patterns. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 5(3), 328–341.
  19. Jokuschies, N., Gut, V., & Conzelmann, A. (2017). Systematizing coaches’ ‘eye for talent’: Player assessments based on expert coaches’ subjective talent criteria in top-level youth soccer. International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching, 12(5), 565–576.
  20. Kannekens, R., Elferink-Gemser, M. T., Post, W. J., & Visscher, C. (2009). Self-assessed tactical skills in elite youth soccer players: A longitudinal study. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 109(2), 459–472.
  21. Khamis, H. J., & Roche, A. F. (1994). Predicting Adult Stature Without Using Skeletal Age: The Khamis-Roche Method. Pediatrics, 94(4), 504–507.
  22. Koo, T. K., & Li, M. Y. (2016). A Guideline of Selecting and Reporting Intraclass Correlation Coefficients for Reliability Research. Journal of Chiropractic Medicine, 15(2), 155–163.
  23. Larkin, P., O’Connor, D. (2017). Talent identification and recruitment in youth soccer: Recruiter’s perceptions of the key attributes for player recruitment. PLoS ONE, 12(4), 1–15.
  24. Liu, H., Gómez, M. A., Gonçalves, B., & Sampaio, J. (2016). Technical performance and match-to-match variation in elite football teams. Journal of Sports Sciences, 34(6), 509–518.
  25. Lloyd, R. S., & Oliver, J. L. (2012). The youth physical development model: A new approach to long-term athletic development. Strength and Conditioning Journal, 34(3), 61–72.
  26. Lüdin, D., Donath, L., Cobley, S., & Romann, M. (2021). Effect of bio-banding on physiological and technical-tactical key performance indicators in youth elite soccer. European Journal of Sport Science, 22(11), 1659-1667.
  27. McCormack, S., Jones, B., Elliott, D., Rotheram, D., & Till, K. (2021). Coaches’ Assessment of Players Physical Performance: Subjective and Objective Measures are needed when Profiling Players. European Journal of Sport Science, 22(8) 1177-1187.
  28. McHugh, M. L. (2012). Interrater reliability: The kappa statistic. Biochemia Medica, 22(3), 276–282.
  29. Metz, L., Deleuze, T., Pereira, B., & Thivel, D. (2015). Section II-Exercise Physiology & Sports Medicine Nutritional Adaptations in Elite Soccer Referees: First Evidence and Perspectives. Journal of Human Kinetics, 46, 77–83.
  30. Milavic, B., Padulo, J., Grgantov, Z., Milić, M., Mannarini, S., Manzoni, G. M., Ardigò, L. P., Rossi, A. (2019). Development and factorial validity of the Psychological Skills Inventory for Sports, Youth Version – Short Form: Assessment of the psychometric properties. PLoS ONE, 14(8) e0220930.
  31. Murr, D., Feichtinger, P., Larkin, P., O’Connor, D., & Höner, O. (2018). Psychological talent predictors in youth soccer: A systematic review of the prognostic relevance of psychomotor, perceptual-cognitive and personality-related factors. PLoS ONE, 13(10), 1–24.
  32. Nimphius, S., Callaghan, S. J., Bezodis, N. E., & Lockie, R. G. (2018). Change of Direction and Agility Tests: Challenging Our Current Measures of Performance. Strength and Conditioning Journal, 40(1), 26–38.
  33. Noon, M. R., Eyre, E. L. J., Ellis, M., Myers, T. D., Morris, R. O., Mundy, P. D., Penny, R., Clarke, N. D. (2020). The Influence of Recruitment Age and Anthropometric and Physical Characteristics on the Development Pathway of English Academy Football Players. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 16(2), 199–207.
  34. Premier League. (2011). Elite Player Performance Plan. Retrieved August 15, 2020, from http://www.premierleague.com/content/premierleague/en-gb/youth/elite-player-performance-plan.html
  35. Rago, V., Brito, J., Figueiredo, P., Ermidis, G., Barreira, D., & Rebelo, A. (2020). The Arrowhead Agility Test: Reliability, Minimum Detectable Change, and Practical Applications in Soccer Players. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 34(2), 483–494.
  36. Roberts, A., Greenwood, D., Stanley, M., Humberstone, C., Iredale, F., & Raynor, A. (2021). Understanding the “gut instinct” of expert coaches during talent identification. Journal of Sports Sciences, 39(4), 359–367.
  37. Roberts, S. J., McRobert, A. P., Lewis, C. J., & Reeves, M. J. (2019). Establishing consensus of position-specific predictors for elite youth soccer in England. Science and Medicine in Football, 3(3), 205–213.
  38. Sarmento, H., Anguera, M. T., Pereira, A., & Araújo, D. (2018). Talent Identification and Development in Male Football: A Systematic Review. Sports Medicine, 48(4), 907–931.
  39. Sieghartsleitner, R., Zuber, C., Zibung, M., & Conzelmann, A. (2013). Prognostic validity of a subjective coach assessment and motor performance tests for talent selection in football: science boosts coaches’ eye! 10th Annual Meeting of the Swiss Society of Sport Science, 89(version 24), 10–12. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323320578
  40. Sieghartsleitner, R., Zuber, C., Zibung, M., & Conzelmann, A. (2019). Science or Coaches’ Eye? - Both! Beneficial Collaboration of Multidimensional Measurements and Coach Assessments for Efficient Talent Selection in Elite Youth Football. Journal of Sports Science & Medicine, 18(1), 32-43.
  41. Sung, Y. T., & Wu, J. S. (2018). The Visual Analogue Scale for Rating, Ranking and Paired-Comparison (VAS-RRP): A new technique for psychological measurement. Behavior Research Methods, 50(4), 1694–1715.
  42. Till, K., & Baker, J. (2020). Challenges and [Possible] Solutions to Optimizing Talent Identification and Development in Sport. Frontiers in Psychology, 11.
  43. Towlson, C., Cope, E., Perry, J. L., Court, D., & Levett, N. (2019). Practitioners’ multi-disciplinary perspectives of soccer talent according to phase of development and playing position. International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching, 14(4), 528–540.
  44. Unnithan, V., White, J., Georgiou, A., Iga, J., & Drust, B. (2012). Talent identification in youth soccer. Journal of Sports Sciences, 30(15), 1719–1726.
  45. Waldron, M., & Worsfold, P. (2010). Differences in the Game Specific Skills of Elite and Sub-Elite Youth Football Players: Implications for Talent Identification. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 10(1), 9–24.
  46. Williams, A. M., Ford, P. R., & Drust, B. (2020). Talent identification and development in soccer since the millennium. Journal of Sports Sciences, 38 (11-12), 1199–1210.